What’s the safest infant car seat? Here’s Our Verdict

Chicco KeyFit ClearTex

Installation: High$

Quick verdict

Verdict
Recommended
Evidence
Moderate

The 22-lb KeyFit earns a Best crash-protection rating and 5/5 vehicle fit from Consumer Reports, but its lower limits mean it may be outgrown sooner.

  • Chicco still sells a standard-fabric 22-lb "KeyFit" ($209.99) alongside this ClearTex version.

Product identity on record: 06087093950070 (Black). Check the current product and version.

Good
  • Consumer Reports: Best crash protection, overall score 88, vehicle fit 5/5 with LATCH and with the belt.
  • Chicco names brominated and chlorinated flame retardants, PFAS, BPA and phthalates as not intentionally added (manufacturer claim).
Caution
  • Rated 4-22 lb and up to 30 in, lower limits than the 30-lb seats here.
  • Only Consumer Reports has tested the KeyFit, and not specifically in ClearTex.

What we could not verify

  • Only one lab has tested the KeyFit, and not specifically in ClearTex.
  • No chemical test located.
Why we reached this verdict

Consumer Reports rates the 22-lb KeyFit's crash protection Best, with an overall score of 88 and 5/5 vehicle fit using LATCH or the belt. CR's listing doesn't identify the fabric, so we treat the result as covering this ClearTex version, which Chicco sells at $169.99 alongside a standard-fabric KeyFit.

Its limits (4-22 lb, up to 30 in) are lower than the 30-lb seats on this page, so it may be outgrown sooner; compare them with your baby's growth before you buy. Chicco's ClearTex statement names flame retardants, PFAS, BPA and phthalates as not intentionally added, a manufacturer claim without published lab results.

Last reviewed .

View evidenceCompare with this productEmail this pageRequest a product

Last reviewed

What we like and what concerns us

Good
  • Consumer Reports: Best crash protection, overall score 88, vehicle fit 5/5 with LATCH and with the belt.
  • Chicco names brominated and chlorinated flame retardants, PFAS, BPA and phthalates as not intentionally added (manufacturer claim).
Caution
  • Rated 4-22 lb and up to 30 in, lower limits than the 30-lb seats here.
  • Only Consumer Reports has tested the KeyFit, and not specifically in ClearTex.
Why we reached this verdict

Verdict: Recommended.

Consumer Reports rates the 22-lb KeyFit's crash protection Best, with an overall score of 88 and 5/5 vehicle fit using LATCH or the belt. CR's listing doesn't identify the fabric, so we treat the result as covering this ClearTex version, which Chicco sells at $169.99 alongside a standard-fabric KeyFit.

Its limits (4-22 lb, up to 30 in) are lower than the 30-lb seats on this page, so it may be outgrown sooner; compare them with your baby's growth before you buy. Chicco's ClearTex statement names flame retardants, PFAS, BPA and phthalates as not intentionally added, a manufacturer claim without published lab results.

Explore materials & ingredients

Open a card to read the disclosure and its sources. Illustrations are conceptual; the recorded evidence below determines what is known.

Explore the evidence

The material claims in the record

4-22 lb KeyFit in ClearTex fabric. Chicco names flame retardants, PFAS, BPA and phthalates. Manufacturer statements; no lab result was located. Category concept: the claims do not establish a complete component breakdown or crash protection.

Category concept, not a product teardown. Shapes do not establish exact construction, layer order or dimensions.
Material claim 1
Recorded claim
ClearTex products have no flame retardant chemicals
Material claim 2
Recorded claim
produced without the use of intentionally added brominated or chlorinated fire retardant chemical treatments, PFAS, BPA and phthalates

Evidence at a glance

Independent crash evidenceCR crash protection Best. Evidence grade A-: One independent program crash tested this model, or tests cover the same seat in a different fabric trim.
Installation and misuse resilienceHigh. CR fit 5/5 for LATCH and belt (3/5 carrier-only). Independent installation scores are strong in the primary methods, with no documented misuse risk.
What the manufacturer says about flame retardants and PFASChicco names flame retardants, PFAS, BPA and phthalates. Manufacturer statements; no lab result was located.
Regulatory statusNo recall of current production located
Exact-model confidenceModerate

Independent crash tests

Consumer Reports and BabyGearLab run their own crash tests with different equipment, methods and scales. Neither publishes raw measurements, so we report each result in the lab's own terms and never combine them. Passing the federal standard is required of every seat and is not a comparative result.

Consumer Reports

Tested as: Chicco KeyFit (4-22 lb). Consumer Reports does not show a test date on the model page.

Same seat; the tested fabric trim is not identified CR's listing is the 4-22 lb KeyFit; it does not identify the fabric trim.

Overall score88 CR Overall Score (0-100; combines crash protection, ease of use and vehicle fit)
Crash protectionBest
Ease of use4/5
Fit to vehicle: LATCH5/5
Fit to vehicle: belt5/5
Fit to vehicle: carrier only3/5
CR RecommendedYes
Limits on the lab's listing4-22 lb; 30 in or less

Source: Consumer Reports, Chicco KeyFit (4-22 lb) car seat review and ratings (accessed September 23, 2026)

Identity and generation notes

  • Chicco still sells a standard-fabric 22-lb "KeyFit" ($209.99) alongside this ClearTex version.

Installation and specifications

Child weight range4-22 lb
Child height limitUp to 30 in
Carrier weight9 lb (manufacturer)
Base weight7 lb (manufacturer)
Lower anchorsPush-on LATCH with SuperCinch tightener
Load legNo
Anti-rebound featureNo
Belt lock-off or tensionerYes
Installs without the baseYes
Rotating baseNo
Car seat and stroller in oneNo

Installation features and lab observations

  • SuperCinch force-multiplying LATCH tightener (Chicco)
  • Two RideRight bubble levels and a ReclineSure leveling foot (Chicco)
  • Integrated belt lock-offs; baseless installation supported (Chicco)
  • EPS energy-absorbing foam (Chicco)
  • No load leg or anti-rebound bar

Features are as described by the manufacturer unless a lab is named. A feature's presence is not evidence of better crash performance on its own.

Federal compliance and recalls

Every seat sold in the US must meet FMVSS 213. The side-impact requirement, FMVSS 213a, applies from December 5, 2026. We did not find a side-impact (FMVSS 213a) statement on the manufacturer page we reviewed.

  • NHTSA 08C007000 (An earlier generation): A 2008 recall of KeyFit and KeyFit 30 bases made February 26 to March 17, 2008. It does not describe current production.

Check your own seat by its model number and manufacture date at nhtsa.gov/recalls, and register it with the manufacturer so recall notices reach you.

Materials and chemical claims

  • “ClearTex products have no flame retardant chemicals” (Chicco, manufacturer statement)
  • “produced without the use of intentionally added brominated or chlorinated fire retardant chemical treatments, PFAS, BPA and phthalates” (Chicco, manufacturer statement)

Certifications claimed: GREENGUARD Gold (manufacturer-stated). GREENGUARD Gold limits chemical emissions (VOCs) into indoor air. It does not test for flame retardants or PFAS, and it says nothing about crash performance. We could not confirm this claim in UL's certification database, which blocks automated checks.

Chicco names flame retardants, PFAS, BPA and phthalates. Manufacturer statements; no lab result was located.

“Free of added flame retardants” means the manufacturer says none were added on purpose. It is not a lab result showing none are present, and no seat on this page has published independent chemical testing.

Price and availability

Listed price$169.99 Source: Chicco, accessed September 23, 2026.
Other prices seenConsumer Reports listing (KeyFit): $169.99-$209.99
Price tier$ $ under $200; $$ $200 to $349.99; $$$ $350 to $549.99; $$$$ $550 and up, by the lowest current price we saw.
AvailabilityIn stock at Chicco
Model numbers06087093950070 (Black)

Prices and stock change often. Price and retailer availability play no part in the verdict.

How this verdict changed

Before the September 23, 2026 re-audit: Recommended, evidence grade A-. Now: Recommended, evidence grade A-.

Re-verified: a current Chicco product with a Best crash rating from Consumer Reports on the KeyFit platform. The 4-22 lb capacity and single-lab evidence are shown as limitations.

What would change our verdict

  • A second independent crash test.
  • Independent testing of the ClearTex fabric.

What we still don't know

  • Only one lab has tested the KeyFit, and not specifically in ClearTex.
  • No chemical test located.

Sources

Every source below was checked on the date shown.

  • KeyFit ClearTex Infant Car Seat, Chicco. Accessed September 23, 2026. Current product name, limits, weights, installation hardware, price and material/chemical claims as stated by the manufacturer on the access date.
  • Chicco KeyFit (4-22 lb) car seat review and ratings, Consumer Reports. Accessed September 23, 2026. Consumer Reports Overall Score 88; crash protection Best; ease of use 4/5; fit-to-vehicle 5/5 LATCH, 5/5 belt, 3/5 carrier-only.
  • NHTSA recall 08C007000: REAR FACING CHILD RESTRAINT SYSTEMS/BASE LATCH, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (Chicco USA, Inc.). Published June 2, 2008. Accessed September 23, 2026. CHICCO USA, INC. IS RECALLING APPROXIMATELY 18,000 BASES USED IN KEYFIT AND KEYFIT 30 REAR-FACING CHILD RESTRAINT SYSTEMS AND IN CORTINA TRAVEL SYSTEMS, AND STAND-ALONE BASES FOR THESE SYSTEMS PURCHASED SEPARATELY, THAT WERE MANUFACTURED BETWEEN FEBRUARY 26 AND MARCH 17, 2008. SOME OF THESE BASES HAVE A DEFECT THAT CAN PREVENT THE BASE FROM BEING TIGHTLY SECURED TO A VEHICLE WHEN THE LOWER LATCH ATTACHMENTS ARE USED AS A METHOD OF INSTALLATION. SPECIFICALLY, WHEN A DEFECTIVE BASE IS INSTALLED WITH THE LOWER LATCH ATTACHMENT STRAPS, THE WEBBING USED TO TIGHTEN THE BASE TO THE VEHICLE SEAT CAN SLIP THROUGH THE ADJUSTMENT LOCK.

Read the category’s editorial sources

Final verdict against our infant car seats standard

Recommended Published as Recommended under the published standard for infant car seats, based on the specific, dated findings above. We apply that standard the same way to every seat on this page, and it doesn't change to fit a favorite See the full site-wide standard for how every category is held to the same process.