What diaper-rash creams are safe? Here’s Our Verdict

The Honest Company Sensitive Everyday Diaper Rash Cream

Avoid$$

Last reviewed

Quick verdict

Lead above 1,600 ppb and cadmium were reported in the tested Sensitive Everyday cream.

The report covers the tested sample, not every batch or every product from this brand. See version details.

Good / Caution / Avoid

Avoid
  • Lead above 1,600 ppb and cadmium were reported in the tested Sensitive Everyday cream.
Caution
  • These findings do not identify the source of the metals within the formula.
Read the original editorial assessment

Verdict: Avoid.

Lead above 1,600 ppb and cadmium were reported in the tested Sensitive Everyday cream. The result is published by Lead Safe Mama with a linked laboratory report. The reported detection is the basis for its Avoid tier under our precautionary standard. The report covers the tested sample, not every batch or every product from this brand. The result does not establish the absorbed dose or the health effects of using this product.

Price tiers are relative within this category and may change over time.

Compare products in this category

Findings on this site reflect the specific products, lots, and formulations examined on the dates cited. Manufacturers change formulations and suppliers without notice; a result reported for one lot does not guarantee the same result for another. Check the "last reviewed" date and the cited source before relying on any finding.

Materials & ingredients

Factors flagged in the editorial review.

Material or ingredientWhat it isConcern levelWhy it's flagged here
Zinc oxideZinc oxide is a mineral compound and the FDA-recognized active ingredient in most diaper-rash ointments and mineral sunscreens — it forms a physical barrier on skin and has a long safety record at the concentrations those products use.Use with cautionThe concern here is the reported metal finding in the finished product. This test does not identify zinc oxide as the source.

Testing history

SourceDateTested forResult
Laboratory testing published by Lead Safe MamaDecember 27, 2025Lead, cadmium, mercury and arsenicLead above 1,600 ppb and cadmium were reported in the tested Sensitive Everyday cream.

Explore the research

What the evidence tells us

Lead above 1,600 ppb and cadmium were reported in the tested Sensitive Everyday cream. Our Avoid rating follows the reported detection, rather than the product’s marketing or certification claims.

What's still uncertain

  • The report covers the tested sample, not every batch or every product from this brand.
  • These findings do not identify the source of the metals within the formula.
  • This review does not establish skin absorption, individual health risk, or current results for an untested lot.
Technical detail & sources

These notes summarize published evidence. We did not commission these tests.

Reported testing

  • Lead, cadmium, mercury and arsenic: Lead above 1,600 ppb and cadmium were reported in the tested Sensitive Everyday cream.. Laboratory testing published by Lead Safe Mama (December 27, 2025). Read the published report.

Sources to read

Read the category’s editorial sources

Final verdict against our diaper-rash creams standard

Avoid Published as Avoid under the published standard for diaper-rash creams, based on the specific, dated findings above. That standard was written before this or any other product on the page was evaluated, and doesn't change to fit a favorite — see the full site-wide standard for how every category is held to the same process.